But reacting in different ways to different things said by (or left unsaid) important people in my life so very long ago . . .
Isn’t critique to help make something better?
Suggestions, exploring alternatives – about message effectiveness – for improvement.
True or False?: Writers have thin skins.
Why is critique so easy to receive from some, yet horrible to accept from others?
Do I rail at those comments, or that commentator, react to their point, or to their sword pushing it home?
Playwright John Osborne said “Asking a working writer what he thinks about critics is like asking a lamppost what if feels about dogs.”
“Write while the heat is in you” … said Thoreau. And, I am.
Did he mean - write when you feel strongly, write when you are filled with passion or rage, caught in the act of being really hot – or should I just turn down my thermostat?
Did he mean ‘wait until tomorrow. With the passage of time, decide whether feelings are still strong enough to write that rebuke’.
Interpreting what others meant by asking them, by having that conversation – that would, I think, be better than saying it was bad or disliked without explanation.
My reactions – my mirror, reminder of my own actions when critics are too forceful, or my own critique when I give it too fully.
When cut by criticism, I ponder whether I don’t know how to handle criticism of that kind, or whether I wish they would switch from scalpel to plastic spoon as they dig into me.
column written/ published from Calgary
morning walk: 9C / 48F, clearing now, fantastic – light shower letting up as we headed up a trail, under a tree canopy, every drop hitting every leaf, pitter-patter music to me – Gusta constipated for some reason, a better problem I suppose than the opposite …
I don't know if you remember me, but, I gave you this email address. I have so enjoyed your columns and writings... Thank you! I was wondering if you are still searching for someone? Your column today gave me the 'courage' (or is hope?) to write you again - as I know I "want someone to play with who"would hopefully enjoy playing with me, AM, Calgary, AB
I also publish FACILITYCalgary, a weekly newsletter, free every Tuesday: to sign up, CLICK HERE
If you liked any Musing column, it would mean a lot to me if you would respond. Comments are welcome, so please contribute to the discussion. To reply, use: firstname.lastname@example.org . You can also connect with me on LinkedIn . You can sign up your friends here at MarkMusing.com . This site is updated daily, each column is retained in the archive when the next day's column is loaded ...